Why have Tories abandoned the hereditaries?

In 1999, during the debate on the House of Lords Bill, Geoff Hoon quoted a passage from the Conservatives’ 1997 campaign guide which read: “It is important to defend the hereditary principle in its own right.”

It is a pity the leadership and even former hereditary Leader of the House, Lord Strathclyde, no longer seem to believe this. For those unfamiliar with the thinking behind the hereditary principle – and the reason it arose in the first place via the institution of monarchy – some of these are detailed below.

The most common misunderstanding of the hereditary principle is that the holders of hereditary titles are somehow better than the rest of us – more intelligent, better bred etc. In the modern day at least it is in fact a convenient way of gathering together a group of people who on the whole share certain circumstantial characteristics that lend themselves well to the role of a House whose primary purpose is to revise legislation.

Firstly, a hereditary House makes its members truly independent of the Executive branch of government, which is nominally vested in the Monarch but today resides in the office of the Prime Minister – who, with a majority, easily controls the House of Commons through the party whips. Peers, while they may belong to political parties (in 1999 there were 299 Conservative hereditary peers, 18 Labour, 23 Lib Dems and 225 Crossbenchers), are not easy to whip as they do not rely on their respective parties to maintain their seat and have no chance of attaining high office.

Which brings us to our second point: ambition. While ambition is important in any society and it is both right and sacred that anyone in this country can aspire to be both a legislator in the House of Commons and Her Majesty’s Prime Minister, ambition and avarice can also lead individuals to do things not in the interests of the people or the nation. Desire for power often leads MPs to support their party leader in votes over their own judgement. Some MPs may be interested only in their salaries, while the way in which others can be bought and sold by vested interests has been only too well documented in the press.

This is, at least, one weakness most hereditary peers do not have. Many are independently wealthy (though, contrary to popular opinion, many peers also work) which reinforces an independence of mind that is an important element of the legislative process. And – while there is no suggestion they are more intelligent or better educated than non-peers – that at least provides a certain benchmark of education that would not be there under a ‘jury service’ House.

An important independence hereditary peers also have is independence from the electorate. While this might sound a aberration and the perfect reason to abolish the House of Lords, it has a positive role alongside an elected House of Commons. Rushed legislation in response to moral panics whipped up by the media, such as the Dangerous Dogs Act, are usually recognised as ridiculous once the dust has settled but their more harmful features can be mitigated by a House which is immune to public opinion. It is worthwhile recalling, too, that an elected chamber is no guarantee of democracy – three million people marched against the invasion of Iraq in 2003 to deaf ears – a decision which has cost this country greatly in both blood and treasure.

The nature of hereditary peerages also means that its holders are, more often than not, ‘mature’ men and women by the time they succeed to their title – amassing a lifetime of experience which is too often missing from the young MPs which are today parachuted into seats straight out of think tanks. Ironically, the name of the chamber which would replace the House of Lords – Senate – derives from the Latin ‘Senatus’ which itself is derived from ‘senex’ meaning ‘old man.’

An important thing to remember is the role of the House of Lords and an Upper Chamber generally in the Parliamentary system. Since 1911, the House of Lords cannot veto or block legislation passed by the House of Commons, only delay its passage through successive amendments. This cemented its role as a chamber primarily concerned with revising legislation.

It is also worth remembering that, despite an imagined class or party bias, the (at that time) completely hereditary House of Lords did not prevent Clement Attlee’s nationalisation of heavy industry, the creation of the NHS or the rise in taxes which created 80-90% brackets for the most wealthy. Nor did the mostly hereditary (after life peers were created in 1958) ‘traditional’ House block ‘progressive’ social legislation such as the Race Relations Act 1965, the Murder (Abolition of Death Penalty) Act 1965, the Abortion Act 1967, the Homosexual Reform Act 1968 or the Equal Pay Act 1970.

These hereditary peers are a great asset to our lawmaking process which we discard at our peril.

Comments

  1. Pingback: Blue Coaster33
  2. Pingback: stream movies
  3. Pingback: Direct TV
  4. Pingback: mobile porn movies
  5. Pingback: stop parking
  6. Pingback: water ionizers
  7. Pingback: stop parking
  8. Pingback: her latest blog
  9. Pingback: electricians tools
  10. Pingback: locksmith 55106
  11. Pingback: more help
  12. Pingback: house blue
  13. Pingback: visit website
  14. Pingback: HD Coloring Pages
  15. Pingback: water ionizer
  16. Pingback: electricity
  17. Pingback: alkaline water
  18. Pingback: alkaline water
  19. Pingback: website
  20. Pingback: loan payment plan
  21. Pingback: weblink
  22. Pingback: read more
  23. Pingback: guitar picks
  24. Pingback: dui attorney
  25. Pingback: security
  26. Pingback: banheira
  27. Pingback: webcam porno
  28. Pingback: guitar picks
  29. Pingback: NBA Online Stream
  30. Pingback: car Hire Jordan
  31. Pingback: private proxies
  32. Pingback: Gym Shorts
  33. Pingback: Fitness Websites
  34. Pingback: guitar picks
  35. Pingback: groupon
  36. Pingback: opensky
  37. Pingback: greenwriting
  38. Pingback: ketone pills
  39. Pingback: porno
  40. Pingback: esta
  41. Pingback: try here
  42. Pingback: ecograf portabil
  43. Pingback: curso de detetive
  44. Pingback: movie2k
  45. Pingback: dr Medora
  46. Pingback: womens swimwear
  47. Pingback: ramalan zodiak
  48. Pingback: dog play pen
  49. Pingback: Krista
  50. Pingback: Amira Griffes
  51. Pingback: no deposit bonus
  52. Pingback: Seo
  53. Pingback: minneapolis seo
  54. Pingback: Escort
  55. Pingback: ebay yarn
  56. Pingback: apple shooter 2
  57. Pingback: Millicent
  58. Pingback: at this link
  59. Pingback: th8 war base
  60. Pingback: poker
  61. Pingback: sacred 3 trainer
  62. Pingback: norse baby names
  63. Pingback: vitamin c serum
  64. Pingback: Jaquelyn
  65. Pingback: tenerife blog
  66. Pingback: Temple Shirakawa
  67. Pingback: hack boom beach
  68. Pingback: movietube
  69. Pingback: guitar picks
  70. Pingback: blogging tools
  71. Pingback: naples cat care
  72. Pingback: Microcapmagazine
  73. Pingback: movietube
  74. Pingback: get d&b number
  75. Pingback: exercise
  76. Pingback: Susanne
  77. Pingback: affiliate
  78. Pingback: ollas rena ware
  79. Pingback: sticky notes rt
  80. Pingback: Cash 4 Clothes
  81. Pingback: tenerife forum
  82. Pingback: party light store
  83. Pingback: chwil�wki
  84. Pingback: na chatroom
  85. Pingback: porno
  86. Pingback: porno
  87. Pingback: mower repair
  88. Pingback: hoer
  89. Pingback: porno
  90. Pingback: click here
  91. Pingback: I was reading this
  92. Pingback: look what I found
  93. Pingback: Fancub Den Haag
  94. Pingback: The Lost Ways
  95. Pingback: jet porn
  96. Pingback: food storage
  97. Pingback: white label casino
  98. Pingback: sleep aid
  99. Pingback: gamelink
  100. Pingback: Full Report
  101. Pingback: Free WSET Course
  102. Pingback: windows and doors
  103. Pingback: hepa air purifiers
  104. Pingback: printing
  105. Pingback: printing vip
  106. Pingback: Ruksis780
  107. Pingback: iv therapy jobs nj
  108. Pingback: blaty drewniane
  109. Pingback: sklejka
  110. Pingback: podlogi drewniane
  111. Pingback: kant�wka dlh
  112. Pingback: counselled
  113. Pingback: isis videos
  114. Pingback: spam scammer
  115. Pingback: stihl fs45 coil
  116. Pingback: Viagra opinie
  117. Pingback: Detroit Lions Blog
  118. Pingback: Discount Code
  119. Pingback: porno
  120. Pingback: Kamagra
  121. Pingback: Comcast
  122. Pingback: Detroit Pistons
  123. Pingback: Fetish Porn
  124. Pingback: Anal Porn
  125. Pingback: Teen XXX Porn
  126. Pingback: Free Amateur Porn
  127. Pingback: Gay Porn
  128. Pingback: Shemale Porn
  129. Pingback: Sophie Dee Porn
  130. Pingback: Reality Kings Porn
  131. Pingback: Amateur Porn
  132. Pingback: Cam Porn
  133. Pingback: Brandi Love Porn
  134. Pingback: Bowling Store
  135. Pingback: Golf Balls
  136. Pingback: AR15kit
  137. Pingback: Magan
  138. Pingback: Cialis bez recepty
  139. Pingback: Luvenia
  140. Pingback: Orlando SEO
  141. Pingback: Levitra apteka
  142. Pingback: irctc login
  143. Pingback: Gabrielle
  144. Pingback: travel singapore
  145. Pingback: Corrina
  146. Pingback: Minecraft Account
  147. Pingback: fast profits today
  148. Pingback: go to this site
  149. Pingback: RRB Result 2016
  150. Pingback: click here
  151. Pingback: Credit Report
  152. Pingback: mypsychicadvice
  153. Pingback: windows and doors
  154. Pingback: coin shop
  155. Pingback: vistos
  156. Pingback: acheter des likes
  157. Pingback: FastComet Coupon
  158. Pingback: click here
  159. Pingback: buy china goods
  160. Pingback: grammar check
  161. Pingback: sex shop
  162. Pingback: PC Disposal
  163. Pingback: Laptop Disposal
  164. Pingback: Computer recycling
  165. Pingback: click here
  166. Pingback: spam software
  167. Pingback: Jacquelyn
  168. Pingback: Nicolette
  169. Pingback: saleforiphone
  170. Pingback: Opciones Binarias
  171. Pingback: memory course
  172. Pingback: CHECK THIS WEBSITE
  173. Pingback: zipcode
  174. Pingback: products-Z
  175. Pingback: my link
  176. Pingback: Diabetes Destroyer
  177. Pingback: fullfilmizle
  178. Pingback: Dallas
  179. Pingback: taxi free
  180. Pingback: thanks
  181. Pingback: generic viagra
  182. Pingback: Atasehir Escort
  183. Pingback: Globalandia
  184. Pingback: Antonio
  185. Pingback: brain smart ultra
  186. Pingback: canada goose
  187. Pingback: Lucky Taxi Boston
  188. Pingback: samsonite carry on
  189. Pingback: sprawdzenie vin
  190. Pingback: his website
  191. Pingback: porno
  192. Pingback: Veterans Day
  193. Pingback: Opciones binarias
  194. Pingback: free wso
  195. Pingback: Guillaume Guersan
  196. Pingback: travis morris dui
  197. Pingback: Hentai
  198. Pingback: Facebook Page
  199. Pingback: useful content
  200. Pingback: Boolberry
  201. Pingback: franchise
  202. Pingback: teh hijau
  203. Pingback: read more
  204. Pingback: Clicking Here
  205. Pingback: read moreÂ…
  206. Pingback: Porno
  207. Pingback: more info here
  208. Pingback: Lauretta
  209. Pingback: Creola
  210. Pingback: tramposos
  211. Pingback: Pawswatch.com
  212. Pingback: infection
  213. Pingback: commercial
  214. Pingback: Polecam
  215. Pingback: conspiracy talk
  216. Pingback: Kamagra oral jelly
  217. Pingback: Visit Website
  218. Pingback: Viagra bez recepty
  219. Pingback: Viagra cena
  220. Pingback: Viagra bez recepty
  221. Pingback: Viagra
  222. Pingback: garcinia cambogia
  223. Pingback: acasa
  224. Pingback: subway surfer
  225. Pingback: steak timer
  226. Pingback: NFL Jerseys China
  227. Pingback: nottingham escort
  228. Pingback: stolen motorcycle
  229. Pingback: temple run 2 game
  230. Pingback: Viagra sklep
  231. Pingback: Viagra sklep
  232. Pingback: lighting
  233. Pingback: bike game
  234. Pingback: shooting
  235. Pingback: Wynell
  236. Pingback: Rayqvon Warren
  237. Pingback: Rayqvon Warren
  238. Pingback: Pam Preston Mize
  239. Pingback: Pam Preston Mize
  240. Pingback: Pam Preston Mize
  241. Pingback: Maryjo
  242. Pingback: Dillon Bostwick
  243. Pingback: fur boots
  244. Pingback: Dr. Maria Karpov
  245. Pingback: HIFU
  246. Pingback: angry birds games
  247. Pingback: Flavia
  248. Pingback: Kristy
  249. Pingback: nottingham escorts
  250. Pingback: izmir escort
  251. Pingback: pendik escort
  252. Pingback: 6MBP100RS060
  253. Pingback: Ermengildo
  254. Pingback: Leicester escorts
  255. Pingback: foro de mierda
  256. Pingback: black quartz
  257. Pingback: epoxy table
  258. Pingback: high rate
  259. Pingback: make money online
  260. Pingback: podnosniki
  261. Pingback: Raye
  262. Pingback: Dillon Bostwick
  263. Pingback: depressione
  264. Pingback: branded kitchen
  265. Pingback: short term loans
  266. Pingback: clash resources
  267. Pingback: coins and gems
  268. Pingback: download lagu
  269. Pingback: top article
  270. Pingback: instagram likes
  271. Pingback: site de rencontre
  272. Pingback: paypal solutions
  273. Pingback: Watch Movies
  274. Pingback: read more
  275. Pingback: Prop oxy
  276. Pingback: cosmetic dentistry
  277. Pingback: Saldo Sodexo
  278. Pingback: Richard Warke
  279. Pingback: Annita
  280. Pingback: jdm engine
  281. Pingback: where to buy
  282. Pingback: judi
  283. Pingback: judi online
  284. Pingback: Porno
  285. Pingback: visit here
  286. Pingback: weee recycling
  287. Pingback: judi
  288. Pingback: deals on cruises
  289. Pingback: CBSE Result 2017
  290. Pingback: Anuthi
  291. Pingback: judi online
  292. Pingback: instagram app
  293. Pingback: go right here
  294. Pingback: buy followers
  295. Pingback: Help Poor
  296. Pingback: url
  297. Pingback: How to sing better
  298. Pingback: Leeann
  299. Pingback: adult sex
  300. Pingback: TAS GUCCI
  301. Pingback: pokemonGo
  302. Pingback: mp3 songs
  303. Pingback: sukanto tanoto
  304. Pingback: call free
  305. Pingback: marker
  306. Pingback: extrato fgts
  307. Pingback: Margo Ducharme
  308. Pingback: local seo packages
  309. Pingback: payday loans
  310. Pingback: cheap seo packages
  311. Pingback: work at home
  312. Pingback: go to site
  313. Pingback: S9 Galaxy
  314. Pingback: https://barzz.net/
  315. Pingback: kawy smakowe
  316. Pingback: mikrozoo
  317. Pingback: 65 4k tv
  318. Pingback: instagram site
  319. Pingback: tenerife property
  320. Pingback: Holy Gold Combo
  321. Pingback: Franco Chain
  322. Pingback: parali poker
  323. Pingback: Kanesha
  324. Pingback: net gambling
  325. Pingback: vps vpn
  326. Pingback: instant followers
  327. Pingback: secure vps hosting
  328. Pingback: Polecam
  329. Pingback: watkins
  330. Pingback: poker online
  331. Pingback: free poker trial
  332. Pingback: email check online
  333. Pingback: showbox
  334. Pingback: showbox
  335. Pingback: email check
  336. Pingback: whois google.com
  337. Pingback: Snaptube ios
  338. Pingback: check my ip
  339. Pingback: Maddie
  340. Pingback: Guide
  341. Pingback: exhibition stands
  342. Pingback: buy phentermine
  343. Pingback: Dr. T. Dędski
  344. Pingback: phen375 reviews
  345. Pingback: Dentist Laredo, TX
  346. Pingback: Dentist Laredo, TX
  347. Pingback: rvsm aircraft
  348. Pingback: www.google.com
  349. Pingback: Hot Eyes Steam
  350. Pingback: photo booth
  351. Pingback: Hot Eyes Steam
  352. Pingback: Chistes
  353. Pingback: fotos graciosas
  354. Pingback: Lille Kejser
  355. Pingback: branding
  356. Pingback: Goki
  357. Pingback: uniforms
  358. Pingback: Inexto
  359. Pingback: buy ig likes
  360. Pingback: Dinosaur exhibitd
  361. Pingback: sex toy coupons
  362. Pingback: Chris Kofitsas
  363. Pingback: Gaming
  364. Pingback: loan sharks
  365. Pingback: Adipex P
  366. Pingback: promoted
  367. Pingback: escort guide
  368. Pingback: poker online ios
  369. Pingback: E-learning
  370. Pingback: escort postings
  371. Pingback: simulations

Comments are closed.